Welcome to Five Islands Lobster Co
Five Islands Lobster Co, located in Georgetown, ME, is a seafood haven renowned for its stunning waterfront views and fresh, delectable dishes. Featured on Yankee magazine's Lobsterpalooza list, the restaurant prides itself on serving some of the best lobster rolls in Maine. Freshly sourced lobsters are often seen being purchased right off the boat, ensuring unparalleled quality. Guests rave about the friendly staff and the charming atmosphere, where one can enjoy a hearty lobster roll alongside crispy fries or a sweet ice cream treat. With multiple shacks for ordering, it offers a unique dining experience with a delightful coastal vibe.
Five Islands Lobster Co: Reviews & Ratings
Finally made it to this spot which is on Yankee magazines 2017 Lobsterpalooza list. Like other spots on this list the location is amazing. We actually watched the owner buying fresh Lobster off the boat (see photos). Lobster roll was amazing. Onion rings SUCKED, half the basket was just fried stuff (see photo), so stick to the fries or whatever. You can also get a whole Lobster and ice cream for desert!
We visited here one Sunday in late June 23’. The food was to die for. I wish I had a larger stomach because I wanted to try everything. Lobster roll was the best I have had in Maine so far. Staff was great as well. Tartar sauce was wet very good. Thanks!
The line moved kind of fast and the staff are very helpful when ordering. People in front of us had a million questions. Lobsters were awesome. We had 3.8 & 2.75 pounders. Meat was tender and filled the shell. Haddock chowder was okay. The view is quite lovely. Good ice cream across the driveway. Thanks Five Islands!
This place is a perfect little in so many ways. The views are stunning, food is wonderful, and there is a pretty good amount of parking! There are three shacks to order from, which was confusing at first. One for lobsters, one for snacks and gear, and one for ice cream. They each have thier own pick up window. Lots of places to sit and enjoy the view in a quiet setting. There is a store down the walkway too if you have time. There is also extra parking at the town lot at the top of the hill. Sidenote: Drive slow coming in! The road is narrow. Cheers!
Such a fun place to stop and eat. Beautiful location and literally sitting on a dock to eat. First lobster roll ever and it did not disappoint! Very busy but moves quickly. Multiple docks and views or either side of the restaurants. Highly recommend.
The best Lobster Roll my husband ever had. The lobster was fresh off the boat and prepared almost right in front of us. The scenery is beautiful to sit outside and enjoy the salty air. You could sit and watch the birds fly past.
Best lobster roll in Maine! Piled high on a homemade grilled potato roll. They say the lobster is sweeter in Georgetown because the water is deeper and colder. I’d have to agree. It’s window service with They outdoor seating and a BYOB policy. So much fun to sit on the water, watching the lobster boats and eat and have a beer or a glass of wine. If you need to grab a beer, there is a general store to the left of the parking lot with a great selection. I can’t stop thinking about their food!!
The freshest lobster and the finest view. Lobster shack right on the water. Outside dining at picinic tables, the full Maine lobster experience. Definitely worth the drive out. Minimalist menu with choose the size of your lobsters, have a look at the live lobsters, then go and enjoy the views while they are expertly cooked. After you are called back to the shack for pickup, you get the joy of shelling and eating your own lobster with butter. As good as it gets!
Location
-
1447 5 Islands Rd, Georgetown, ME 04548, United States Hotline: +1 207-371-2990
Nestled in the picturesque landscape of Georgetown, Maine, Five Islands Lobster Co. is not just a seafood shack—it's a culinary haven for those who appreciate the art of lobster cuisine. With a prime location at 1447 5 Islands Rd, this gem has earned its spot on Yankee Magazine's 2017 Lobsterpalooza list, and for very good reason.
As you approach, the excitement builds. You might even catch a glimpse of the owner procuring fresh lobsters right off the boat, a testament to the restaurant's commitment to source only the best ingredients. The star of the menu is undoubtedly the renowned lobster roll. Customers rave about its extraordinary flavor, claiming it to be the best they've tasted in Maine. It's a dish that truly embodies the essence of coastal dining.
The overall experience at Five Islands Lobster Co. goes beyond the food. The stunning waterfront views enhance your meal, providing a serene backdrop that makes dining here memorable. Whether you choose to sit directly on the dock or on one of the many available picnic tables, the atmosphere is undeniably inviting. This is a place where you can relish your lobster roll while soaking in the beauty of Maine's coastline.
While reviews do mention some mixed opinions regarding side options like onion rings, the consensus is clear: stick with the fries or perhaps splurge on a whole lobster. And don’t forget to leave room for some homemade ice cream—it’s a sweet way to wrap up your coastal feast.
With a friendly and attentive staff ready to guide you through their extensive menu, you’ll feel right at home. Whether you're a seasoned lobster lover or a first-timer looking to savor your very first roll, Five Islands Lobster Co. promises an unforgettable experience. Make the journey to this Maine treasure, and you’ll understand why it creates a buzz among locals and tourists alike.
For any inquiries or to plan your visit, you can reach them at +1 207-371-2990. Come for the lobster; stay for the views!